10 Best Gift Baskets Consumer Reports 2019 – Top Rated

We enlisted 20 coworkers to taste test 11 gift baskets from the top gift basket companies. The best overall gift basket is the Founders’ Favorite Gift Box from Harry & David because it features delicious, ripe fruit and snacks that are unique and tasty. If you’re a cheese connoisseur or interested in trying more gourmet foods, we recommend the California Classic Gift Basket from igourmet.com. If you want the largest basket for a comparable price, the Gourmet Choice basket from Wine Country Gift Baskets is best.

Top 10 Gift Baskets

Bestseller No. 1
Biscotti Cookie Gift Basket, Gourmet Gift Basket, Delicious Biscotti Artfully Decorated 18 Count...
543 Reviews
Biscotti Cookie Gift Basket, Gourmet Gift Basket, Delicious Biscotti Artfully Decorated 18 Count...
  • IMPRESS WITH THE BEST: Present this beautiful Oh! Nuts tray of decorated biscotti to leave a memorable...
  • INCREDIBLY LUSCIOUS RICH TASTE: You and your family will enjoy the unique flavors of these festive biscotti...
Bestseller No. 2
Chocolate, Caramel and Crunch Grand Gift Basket
657 Reviews
Chocolate, Caramel and Crunch Grand Gift Basket
  • Perfect for anyone who loves to snack! A decadent gift basket of chocolate, caramel, and crunchy gourmet...
  • Two buttery and crisp caramel corns, traditional and chocolate drizzled, plus rich peanut brittle
Bestseller No. 3
Barnett's Chocolate Cookies Gift Basket, Gourmet Christmas Holiday Corporate Food Gifts in Elegant...
1344 Reviews
Barnett's Chocolate Cookies Gift Basket, Gourmet Christmas Holiday Corporate Food Gifts in Elegant...
  • ELEGANT GIFT BOX, 12 CHOCOLATE COVERED COOKIES: Twelve delicious gourmet Chocolate covered sandwich cookies in...
  • TWELVE DELIGHTFUL FLAVORS: Each hand dipped in premium dark chocolate, Covered with twelve sweet assorted...
Bestseller No. 4
Classic Gourmet Fruit Basket Gift
610 Reviews
Classic Gourmet Fruit Basket Gift
  • Orchard favorite fruits including two varieties of pears, two varieties of apples, oranges and mandarins, and...
  • A delicious natural cheddar cheese (in warm weather, cheese will be substituted with 7 oz. Jar Artichoke...
Bestseller No. 5
Oh! Nuts Chocolate Covered Cookie Gift Baskets, 20 Variety Gourmet Assortment Set Holiday Food...
397 Reviews
Oh! Nuts Chocolate Covered Cookie Gift Baskets, 20 Variety Gourmet Assortment Set Holiday Food...
  • PRESENT A GIFT THAT LEAVES A MEMORABLE IMPRESSION: This beautiful Oh! Nuts tray contains an assortment of 20...
  • INCREDIBLY LUSCIOUS RICH TASTE: You and your family will enjoy the unique flavors of these festive sandwich...
Bestseller No. 6
Hickory Farms Hearty Selection
103 Reviews
Hickory Farms Hearty Selection
  • (3) 10 ounce Our Signature Beef Summer Sausage
  • 6 ounce Smoked Gouda, 6 ounce Harvest Vegetable White Cheddar Blend
Bestseller No. 7
Bath and Body Gift Basket For Women & Men – Magnolia and Jasmine Home Spa Set, Includes Fragrant...
27 Reviews
Bath and Body Gift Basket For Women & Men – Magnolia and Jasmine Home Spa Set, Includes Fragrant...
  • DELUXE 13 PIECE SET ♥ This spa gift basket has everything a woman needs! It includes Shower Gel, Bubble...
  • SWEET MAGNOLIA & RELAXING JASMINE ♥ The subtle sweet citrus tones of magnolia combine with the calming notes...
Bestseller No. 8
Token of Appreciation Gift Tower The Perfect Gift Basket for Mothers Day, Birthdays, Sympathy or Any...
354 Reviews
Token of Appreciation Gift Tower The Perfect Gift Basket for Mothers Day, Birthdays, Sympathy or Any...
  • Great gift for Mothers Day Gift Basket, Mother's Day gifts, dad friends, family & co-workers, birthday,...
  • Perfect gift basket for family and friends, or as a corporate office gift
Bestseller No. 9
Mother's Day Nuts Gift Basket - Gourmet Food Gifts Prime Delivery - Christmas, Holiday & Fathers Day...
4940 Reviews
Mother's Day Nuts Gift Basket - Gourmet Food Gifts Prime Delivery - Christmas, Holiday & Fathers Day...
  • OVER TWO POUNDS OF DELICIOUS NUTS: All nuts that made it into this gift tray were hand selected for quality...
  • FESTIVELY PRESENTED AND ARTFULLY DECORATED: Our designers have chosen to encase this fruit and nut gift...
Bestseller No. 10
Wine Country Gift Baskets Ghirardelli Tower
228 Reviews
Wine Country Gift Baskets Ghirardelli Tower
  • It features an assortment of milk and dark chocolate squares, dark chocolate drops, milk and dark chocolate...
  • This tantalizing gift tower features a premium selection of traditional favorites from America's much-loved...

Why Trust Us

We spent 30 hours researching and reviewing comparable gift baskets from 11 companies to find the best and most delicious gift ideas. Writers at Top Ten Reviews have covered and compared gift baskets for several years, and this is a product that we’re familiar with. We bought the gift baskets and took careful notes on the baskets each company offers, the shipping options available and how the baskets were delivered to our offices.

How We Tested

To test gift baskets, we ordered 11 baskets that cost around $100 from each of the top companies we researched. We took careful notes of how the baskets arrived and what condition they were in before we opened them up and spread the contents out in our break room. We gave each of our testers a ballot with the names of each basket and room to rate five food items from each basket. We also had our testers vote on the best basket overall and any food items that exceeded expectations. We then collected all the ratings and ranked baskets by the average of all the food scores.

How Much Do Gift Baskets Cost?

The baskets we ordered for testing all cost about $100 and each came with a significant amount of food and other products. More extravagant and larger gift baskets are priced around $300, but there are also plenty available closer to the $40 range. Keep in mind many companies tack on fees if shipping requires an ice pack or another special handling. Of course, how much a gift basket is going to cost is dependent on the size of the basket, and how decadent the foods are.

Laws

Some state laws regulate the shipment of alcoholic beverages to consumers. These laws vary, but according to the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL), you cannot ship alcohol to private addresses in Alabama, Oklahoma, and Utah. This includes shipping gift baskets containing alcohol to your friends and family in these states, so shop accordingly.

Allergies

Keep in mind while shopping that not everyone can enjoy everything offered in a gift basket. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, food allergies among children have become more common over time. The reported food allergy rate for children increased by 18 percent from 1997 to 2007 alone. About 65 percent of humans have a reduced ability to digest lactose after infancy, according to the U.S.

Best Gift Baskets for the Ketogenic Diet

One of the newest health crazes, the ketogenic diet, is a low-carb, high-fat diet plan. Users are encouraged to all but eliminate carbohydrates and replace them with fats. That way, your body only burns fat for energy, oftentimes causing weight loss. There are variations of the ketogenic diet, according to Healthline, but as a general rule carbohydrates are eliminated. Finding a keto-friendly gift basket can be hard, but they do exist. Look for gift baskets with cheese and meat but no crackers. You should also avoid sugar-laden gift baskets or those that include a lot of chocolate.

Seasonality

Keep the season in mind when shopping for gift baskets. While many ships with cold packs to keep perishable items fresh, they’re not foolproof. Also, they won’t keep a basket fresh if you don’t see the delivery notification and the food sits on the porch in the sun. Buying items that are appropriate for the time of year can save you the heartache of having a basket inadvertently ruined in the mail.

Gift Basket Subscriptions

Whether it’s cosmetics, clothing or food, there are a lot of subscription services you can use to get fun products delivered every single month. This is true when it comes to gift baskets as well. Harry and David have several Fruit of the Month Club baskets to order. You pay once and can have the basket delivered once each subsequent month. These baskets come with a variety of pears, mixed nuts, apples, crackers, and other goodies. There are also themed Fruit of the Month Club baskets for various holidays.

Diet Gift Baskets

There are a lot of options for people who are watching what they eat. Whether a person is trying to lose weight or simply maintain where they are, it’s important to respect their dietary choices and not gift them with, say, a gift basket full of chocolates. There are a lot of other alternatives to pick from, whether they’re full of fruits, gluten-free bread or protein-rich nuts.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here